Does not count as a genuine contribution to the world. Appraising other’s passions is an unhelpful thing to be passionate about. Critical reviews of others’ expressions of joyful creativity only stifle further joyful creativity.
You’re so creative with your reviews
Of what other people do
How satisfying that must be for you
David Bazan, “Selling Advertising”
Leave her alone. Leave him alone. Your criticism says more about you than anyone else.